Now Open!
New York Butcher Shoppe|9361 Montgomery Road, Montgomery, OH 45242|(513) 745-0968
5.0 stars | 40 reviews
RARE QUALITY. WELL DONE SERVICE.
PREMIUM CUTS
OF FRESH MEATS.
(513) 745-0968Contact Us

A PREMIER BUTCHER SHOP, IN Montgomery, OH

Your Montgomery, OH butcher and more: specialty meat market, food and wine selections for any occasion!

Google icon
N A
3 days ago
EXCELLENT STEAKS! This place will do very well. They offer quality products and quality cuts at a very good price. Add to it the location and the warm service. I am very pleased and encourage you to support this small...
Google icon
Sheryll Barraco
1 week ago
Stopped in today to check this place out. We were warmly welcomed right away. The space is beautiful and filled with all sorts of wonderful things! The refrigerated case had various side dishes (to complement the delectable...
Google icon
Victoria Griffin
1 week ago
We’ve tried so many things and there’s not been one bad thing to say. The staff is so friendly and will make sure you find what you need as well. So happy we have a local butcher so close to home. Can’t wait to try everything!
Google icon
Hudson Heidorf
1 week ago
I visited the NY Butcher Shop this weekend. The meats were beautifully displayed and everything looked fresh and high quality. The staff was welcoming, knowledgeable, and made the experience even better by offering a variety...
Google icon
Sarah Atwell
1 week ago
Love this place! The staff is super friendly and welcoming and the shop couldn’t be more clean and well-organized. Highly recommend!
Google icon
Judy Miracle
2 weeks ago
We had the best cheeseburgers for dinner using the Nati Burger blend cooked in the skillet with Bacon Up bacon grease. Very tasty and juicy - they were so good we had them 2 nights in a row! We did try the Tomatoe Bisque which...

WIDEST SELECTION OF

FRESH MEATS

All of our beef cuts are Certified Angus Beef and selected from only the highest quality Angus farms across the country. Our cuts are always Top Choice or Prime which provides well-marbled, very tender, consistent steaks. Each week we feature a different specialty item, from Wagyu beef to custom meat grinds, to ensure you have something fresh and delicious to take home each day. Whether you are loading up the grill for your next gathering or looking to treat your family to a quality roast, stop by today to view our selection.

Browse Our

Wine Selection

Complete your meal with New York Butcher Shoppe's curated collection of high-end wines. From the refreshing Sauvignon Blanc, to the full-bodied Viognier, to a light and classic Pinot Grigio or Riesling, each wine is meticulously chosen to elevate your dining affair. Indulge in the robust reds like Bordeaux, Malbec, and Cabernet Sauvignon, or a light-bodied Pinot Noir - be sure to ask our staff for their latest recommendations. Complete your celebration with your choice of Champagne and end the evening with a dessert wine. Be sure to explore unique gourmet mixers, local craft selections, and small-batch tonic for an exquisite touch to your libations.

Locally-Sourced

Specialty Grocery

Elevate your pantry with a curated selection of specialty items, such as gourmet pastas, specialty cheeses, and high-quality vegetables. Our options are perfect for creating exquisite charcuterie boards, thoughtful gifts, or enhancing your culinary repertoire. In addition to unique condiments and premium cuts of meat, we stock our shelves with international grocery items and seasonings to bring extra flavor to every kitchen. Stop by to add a touch of sophistication to your dinner table.

Delicious and Convenient

Prepared Meals

Simplify your culinary adventure with New York Butcher Shoppe's exquisite ready-to-eat and ready-to-cook prepared foods - where every dish is available for easy ordering or convenient pickup. All of our recipes are crafted in house to offer a tantalizing range of options for every palate. We offer classic options like seasoned and stuffed meats, salads, and sides, but be sure to check out our rotating menu of specialty and seasonal meals. Share our home-cooked delights with your crew tonight!

Butcher In Montgomery, OH

Get ready for a prime experience you won’t forget anytime soon. New York Butcher Shoppe is a butcher providing our customers with delicious gourmet foods. Whether you’re hungry for one of our prepared foods or fresh meat, we’re prepared to serve you an unforgettable meal every time you visit us.

OUR BUTCHER SERVES:

  • Premium Cuts of Meat
  • Seasoned & Stuffed Meats
  • Prepared Meals
  • Prepared Salads & Side Dishes
  • Wine & More!

A memorable meal awaits you at New York Butcher Shoppe. Join us for lunch or dinner today!

Contact Us

Contact Us

Business Hours

Monday10:00AM-7:00PM
Tuesday10:00AM-7:00PM
Wednesday10:00AM-7:00PM
Thursday10:00AM-7:00PM
Friday10:00AM-7:00PM
Saturday10:00AM-7:00PM

Social

Our Reviews

5.0 stars | 40 reviews
Copyright © 2025 New York Butcher Shoppe, All rights reserved.